Menu

The COP has lost sight of nature: Managing our interference is not the same as preventing it

We have become increasingly sophisticated at accounting for our interference with nature, but insufficiently serious about reducing it. The purpose of climate action should be to change that relationship, not simply to manage its consequences.

Published Nov 19, 2026 | 7:00 AM ⚊ Updated Nov 19, 2026 | 7:00 AM

UN Climate Change Conference (COP31)
Make Us Your Preferred Source on Google

Synopsis: As COP31 enters its decisive phase in Antalya, Türkiye, climate negotiations risk becoming an elaborate exercise in carbon accounting, financial engineering and technological promises, while losing sight of the original purpose of the climate convention: preventing dangerous human interference with the climate system.

The United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change (UNFCCC) is remarkably clear about its ultimate objective.

Article 2 calls for the stabilisation of greenhouse gas concentrations in the atmosphere at a level that prevents “dangerous anthropogenic interference with the climate system”. It further requires this to happen within a timeframe that allows ecosystems to adapt naturally, food production to remain secure and economic development to proceed sustainably.

Thirty-two years after the Convention entered into force, as COP31 enters its decisive phase in Antalya, it is worth asking whether the climate negotiations are still guided by this objective. Or have they become increasingly preoccupied with the instruments, markets, accounting systems and financial arrangements created in the name of climate action?

The distinction is fundamental. Carbon markets, net-zero commitments, climate finance and technological interventions can all contribute to addressing climate change. But they are means, not ends. Their value must ultimately be judged by whether they reduce human interference with the climate system and protect the natural processes that sustain life. Increasingly, there is reason to worry that the means are becoming the agenda.

Managing interference rather than preventing it

Consider the growing importance of carbon markets.

Article 6 of the Paris Agreement enables countries to cooperate through internationally transferred mitigation outcomes and a UN-supervised carbon-crediting mechanism. Properly designed, these mechanisms can mobilise finance and support emissions reductions. But they also introduce a troubling possibility: that reducing emissions becomes an accounting exercise in which the ability to purchase credits substitutes for the responsibility to change energy and production systems.

The atmosphere does not recognise carbon credits. It responds to the actual concentration of greenhouse gases. A credit represents a climate benefit only if it corresponds to a genuine, additional and appropriately accounted-for reduction or removal. If it allows emissions to continue elsewhere without an equivalent climate benefit, it merely redistributes the claim to having acted.

Further, net zero may appear as essential for stabilising global temperatures. But its political and commercial interpretation can be considerably less demanding. Governments and corporations can announce targets decades into the future while continuing to invest in fossil-fuel infrastructure today, relying on anticipated carbon removals, offsets or technologies to compensate for emissions later.

The danger is that the language of climate ambition survives even when the substance of mitigation is postponed. Net zero should describe the destination reached through deep and sustained emissions reductions, not become an accounting licence for continuing business as usual.

Nature is not simply a carbon asset

There is a more fundamental dimension to the Convention’s objective that receives insufficient attention in these negotiations: nature’s own capacity to recover.

Forests, oceans, wetlands, grasslands and soils are not merely carbon sinks. They are complex living systems with regenerative processes that support biodiversity, water cycles, food production and climate regulation. When destructive pressures are removed, many ecosystems can recover and restore ecological functions. Protecting a forest, for instance, is not simply about preserving the quantity of carbon stored in its trees. It is also about protecting its biodiversity, soil, hydrology, relationship with surrounding landscapes and the livelihoods dependent on it.

But nature’s regenerative capacity is neither unlimited nor guaranteed. Repeated forest fires, deforestation, pollution, ocean warming and habitat destruction can push ecosystems towards irreversible damage. Climate change itself increasingly undermines the ability of natural systems to recover.

This suggests three complementary priorities for climate action: reduce the human activities that destabilise natural systems; protect and restore the ecosystems that can regenerate; and deploy technology to address emissions and damage that cannot otherwise be avoided.

The order matters. Renewable energy, storage, cleaner industrial processes, methane detection and better forest-fire monitoring have essential roles. Carbon removal technologies may also be necessary for residual emissions. But technological intervention cannot become an excuse for postponing emissions reductions or allowing ecosystems to deteriorate in the expectation that future innovations will repair them.

The objective should be to work with nature’s regenerative capacity, not to assume that technology can indefinitely compensate for its destruction.

The Indian perspective

This distinction is particularly important for India. The country has rightly argued that climate action must recognise historical responsibility, unequal capabilities and the development needs of poorer populations. Its insistence on climate finance and technology transfer is grounded in the principles of equity and common but differentiated responsibilities.

But India’s climate challenge cannot be understood exclusively through emissions targets or energy transitions. Its forests, rivers, wetlands, mangroves, agricultural landscapes and coastal ecosystems are essential to water security, livelihoods, food production and resilience against extreme weather.

Protecting these systems is not a secondary environmental objective to be pursued alongside climate policy. It is central to climate action itself. At the same time, India must accelerate its transition away from coal, reduce emissions from industry and transport, and address the pressures that urbanisation, infrastructure expansion and changing consumption patterns place on natural systems.

There is also an important distributional dimension. A forest-dependent community, a small farmer exposed to erratic rainfall and an urban household facing extreme heat experience environmental degradation very differently from those who benefit from carbon-intensive economic activity. Climate policy must therefore ask not only how much carbon is reduced or removed, but who benefits from the transition and who bears its costs.

For India, defending climate justice internationally and protecting ecological integrity domestically should be inseparable objectives.

Returning to the purpose of the COP

None of this requires abandoning carbon markets, net-zero targets or technological innovation. It requires restoring their proper place in the hierarchy of climate action.

Every negotiating track at COP31 should face a simple test. Does it accelerate actual emissions reductions? Does it prevent further degradation of natural systems? Does it strengthen the capacity of ecosystems and communities to adapt? Does it make polluters more accountable, or merely make their emissions easier to account for?

These questions matter because the architecture of climate governance is becoming increasingly sophisticated, even as the physical climate crisis intensifies. We are negotiating how emissions can be traded, how reductions can be credited, how finance can be mobilised and how future removals can be recognised. Yet agreement on moving away from fossil fuels remains politically difficult, and the financial and technological support needed by developing countries remains inadequate.

The Convention was not established to create an elaborate global system for managing humanity’s interference with nature. It was established to prevent that interference from becoming dangerous.

Perhaps the most important climate intervention is also the most fundamental: stop doing what is destabilising the Earth’s natural systems, give those systems the space and protection to recover, and use human ingenuity and technology to support that process.

COP31 should be judged not by the sophistication of its carbon accounting, the volume of credits traded or the number of net-zero pledges reiterated. It should be judged by whether it brings the world closer to the original purpose of the Convention.

We should be spending less time perfecting the mechanisms for managing our interference with nature, and considerably more time reducing it. That is what climate action was meant to be about.

Also Read:

Sixth extinction: Humanity’s assault on Earth’s biodiversity

The human body has limits. Climate change is testing them on the playing field

Super El Niño: Karnataka may lose 1,870 lives, Andhra Pradesh and Kerala 1,680 each

(Edited by R Rajesh Kumar.)

journalist-ad