Friday, March 24, 2023
  • Login
The South First
Advertisement
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Videos
  • Dakshin Dialogues
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Videos
  • Dakshin Dialogues
No Result
View All Result
The South First
No Result
View All Result

Home » Health » Karnataka doctors fume as Health Department suggests telenephrology for its dialysis centres

Karnataka doctors fume as Health Department suggests telenephrology for its dialysis centres

Nephrologists from districts raise serious concerns about this option, say hiring of nephrologists is a must and telemedicine can be only supportive

Chetana BelagerebyChetana Belagere
Published:23/01/2023 2:20 am
A A
Representational image

Representational image of tele nephrology. (Wikimedia Commons)

After much criticism and delay, the Karnataka government has finally floated tenders for companies to instal, operate and manage the hemodialysis units in the district and taluk levels to handle dialysis centres in the districts.

However, the state government has now stated that nephrologists may physically visit the centres once every 15 days or provide teleconsultation.

This, after it ignored the important issue of the presence of nephrologists in these dialysis centres for the last few years.

Nephrologists in the districts have taken objection to the latest decision of the state government.

“This is detrimental to patients and nephrologists. Dialysis management is a dynamic process. It cannot be managed completely through telenephrology, like CT or MRI reporting done by radiologists remotely,” said Dr Ravi R, a nephrologist from Karnataka.

The plan and its apparent drawbacks

The final draft of the tender floated by Karnataka’s Department of Health and Family Welfare, a copy of which is available with South First, called companies to provide one nephrologist per district, with a qualification of DM (Nephrology or Renal Dialysis Technology or Fellowship in Renal Dialysis from a recognised university.

The draft says, “nephrologist shall conduct physical consultation or teleconsultation fortnightly at the district hospital)”

Representational pic of a dialysis unit in government hospital.
Representational pic of a dialysis unit in a government hospital. (Wikimedia Commons)

Nephrologists, in conversation with South First, expressed concerns that so far a majority of the dialysis centres in the state had not even appointed a nephrologist, and the technicians and sometimes even untrained nurses were doing the dialysis.

It may be noted that this was reported by South First.

The Mumbai-based Kidney Warrior Foundation, in its own investigation, found the same situation.

The concern of nephrologists was that if the tender floated for the new company to run the dialysis centres under the PPP (public-private partnership) model was given the option of either visit or teleconsultation by nephrologists, the private agencies might opt for teleconsultation only, and that can be dangerous for the dialysis patient.”

Interestingly, several doctors from districts, whom South First spoke to, were against mentioning their names fearing action from the government and the health department.

A nephrologist from North Karnataka said, “In my opinion, a nephrologist has to compulsorily be appointed by these agencies. Whenever we suggest any options, we need to consider evidence-based trials. There are no studies, to my knowledge, to show that teleconsultation is not inferior to physical consultation. We have to at least show non-inferiority before we suggest this as an option. Even if we are unable to show superiority, that means teleconsultation works in dialysis patients, we have to show non-inferiority, or it is equivalent.”

Another doctor argued that an option like this may be worked out if there were no nephrologists available in the state, but then there is no dearth of nephrologists.

“Why is the state government not appointing them? The reason mainly is they want to hire the nephrologists at a cheaper rate, for as low as ₹10,000-15,000 a month, which is not going to be acceptable to any nephrologist. This option is being worked out by the health ministry in Karnataka to make way for private players to function under the garb of providing teleconsultation to dialysis patients,” he said.

Telemedicine is the way forward?

However, the doctors even argued that considering the fact that telemedicine was being pushed big time in healthcare management in India, the state government should first weigh the pros and cons of providing telemedicine as an option in some portions of disease management.

The doctors argued that as dialysis patients were very sick and needed constant monitoring, physical checks on them were important.

Meanwhile, another nephrologist — from a private hospital in New Delhi — told South First that telemedicine could be considered as an option, provided the nephrologist visited the centre and met the patient at least once in 15 days.

“This means the centre definitely needs to have a nephrologist on board, and an MBBS doctor who has had at least six months of training in the dialysis unit has to be present all the time. Teleconsultation without a nephrologist visiting the centre, seeing the patients, and advising on changes in their dialysis units has to compulsorily happen,” said the doctor.

Meanwhile, a nephrologist from Vijayapura in Karnataka told South First that the system was functioning well when industrialist BR Shetty’s company was managing the dialysis centres well with the appointment of nephrologists, with the maintenance of the machines and RO units as well.

If they could do it, why can’t the new companies, asked the doctor.

“In the last three years, 50 percent of dialysis patients in government hospitals have lost their lives, and the remaining are very ill due to inadequate dialysis in non-supervised, non-serviced dialysis machines and poor-quality water being used from non-serviced RO plants,” he said.

“If the government really intends to do a thorough check, they can do a death audit then the number of patient deaths and the problems they are facing is all very obvious. Who is checking though?” he asked.

Don't miss our top stories!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more information.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Recommended For You

The court also asked the party to submit the list of national and state leaders who will be participating in the dharna. (Wikimedia Commons)
News

TSPSC paper leak: Telangana High Court allows BJP to hold ‘Maha Dharna’ protest

March 24, 2023
Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge said that Narendra Modi government is most afraid of Rahul Gandhi and the Congress party. (Twitter/INCIndia)
Karnataka

Allies, rival parties alike decry Rahul Gandhi disqualification; call for united front grows louder

March 24, 2023
Andhra Pradesh CM YS Jagan speaking in the Assembly. (Screengrab)
Andhra Pradesh

Andhra Pradesh Assembly urges Centre to provide  SC status to Dalit Christians, include Boyas in ST list

March 24, 2023
OBBs by the current YSRCP government had always come under criticism from the Opposition — especially the TDP.
Andhra Pradesh

Andhra Pradesh off-budget borrowings at ₹1.18 L cr; overall liability ₹4.91 L cr: CAG

March 24, 2023
'Can Bandi Sanjay or any other BJP leader prove that there were states who were paying more than ₹10,000 per acre to rain-affected farmers?' asked Harish. (Harish Rao/Twitter)
News

Harish Rao, KTR slam Bandi Sanjay for picking holes in KCR’s farmer compensation announcement

March 24, 2023
Prime Minister Narendra Modi neither mentioned the name of Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai nor praised him during Shivamogga and Belagavi event on Monday. (CMO)
Karnataka

Karnataka urges Central government to include SC, ST quota hike in 9th Schedule

March 24, 2023

Top Stories

Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge said that Narendra Modi government is most afraid of Rahul Gandhi and the Congress party. (Twitter/INCIndia)

Allies, rival parties alike decry Rahul Gandhi disqualification; call for united front grows louder

March 24, 2023
Former Lakshadweep MP Mohammad Faizal. (Supplied)

Mohammed Faizal case: Conviction stayed or not, wait for Rahul Gandhi to be MP again may be long

March 24, 2023
Amit Shah Vijayendra

Karnataka: At BS Yediyurappa breakfast meet, Amit Shah puts BY Vijayendra-baiters in BJP on backfoot

March 24, 2023

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive daily updates direct to your inbox.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Like and Follow

Follow @TheSouthfirst

Latest

The court also asked the party to submit the list of national and state leaders who will be participating in the dharna. (Wikimedia Commons)

TSPSC paper leak: Telangana High Court allows BJP to hold ‘Maha Dharna’ protest

March 24, 2023
Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge said that Narendra Modi government is most afraid of Rahul Gandhi and the Congress party. (Twitter/INCIndia)

Allies, rival parties alike decry Rahul Gandhi disqualification; call for united front grows louder

March 24, 2023
Andhra Pradesh CM YS Jagan speaking in the Assembly. (Screengrab)

Andhra Pradesh Assembly urges Centre to provide  SC status to Dalit Christians, include Boyas in ST list

March 24, 2023
The South First

CATEGORIES

  • News
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Featured
  • Health & Wellness
  • Andhra Pradesh
  • Karnataka
  • Kerala
  • Tamil Nadu
  • Telangana

PAGES

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2023 The South First

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Health & Wellness
  • Dakshin Dialogues
  • Videos

© 2023 The South First

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our