If journalism falters, democracy will collapse, says former SC Justice BN Srikrishna at RedInk awards event

Published Dec 17, 2022 | 4:03 PMUpdated Dec 17, 2022 | 4:03 PM

RedInk awards

Eminent journalist, author and former editorial advisor of The New Indian Express TJS George was presented with the coveted National RedInk Award for ‘Lifetime Achievement’ at a glittering function in Mumbai on Friday, 16 December.

The RedInk Awards, constituted by the Mumbai Press Club, were presented to journalists excelling in 12 categories

Earlier, addressing the awards function, eminent jurist Justice (Retd) BN Srikrishna said that if journalism as a profession falters, democracy will collapse.

The retired Supreme Court judge, who has headed several investigation panels, including the inquiry commission for the Mumbai 1992-93 riots, urged journalists to “speak the truth to the powers that be”.

“There are two professions — the judge and the journalist — who have to side with the truth. If they falter, democracy will collapse,” Justice Srikrishna said, addressing the awards event organised by the Mumbai Press Club.

“We all know about the four pillars of democracy … judiciary, legislature, executive and the press or the fourth estate. If the first three cosy up, it’s the duty of the fourth estate to take them to task,” he said.

Misuse of probe agencies

Justice Srikrishna recalled the days of Emergency and agreed that investigative agencies are now being misused. “People spoke of threats from ED, CBI… surveillance, cutting off revenue to see that businesses collapse,” he added. “In such a situation, honesty is the best policy.”

RedInk awards

Journalist of the Year Om Gaur of the Dainik Bhaskar group. (Supplied)

At the ceremony held at NCPA’s Jamshed Bhaba Hall in South Mumbai, as many as 26 journalists from all over the country received RedInk Awards for categories ranging from political writing and environment to healthcare and business.

Award recipients included Om Gaur, national editor of Dainik Bhaskar, who bagged the ‘Journalist of the Year’ award for leading a team of reporters and photographers that tirelessly exposed the tragedy of Covid-19 deaths in Uttar Pradesh’s towns and cities along the Ganga river.

Earlier, at a riveting debate on Is There a Future for Independent News Media?, former Mumbai Police chief MN Singh, well-known criminal lawyer Satish Maneshinde, and veteran advertising executive Meenakshi Menon discussed whether the media was facing “an undeclared Emergency”.

Journalists face stringent laws 

Singh, the cop who oversaw the investigation in the Mumbai blast case, said that he does not think India has become unsafe for journalists. He, however, conceded that many stringent laws, including the one on sedition, “were now being used against journalists, which should not happen”.

RedInk Awards

Veteran journalist TJS George receiving the Lifetime Achievement award at the RedInk event. (Supplied)

Maneshinde said that he had seen the press since the emergency. “The charge of sedition (laws) had been a handle used by governments against the press.”

He lamented that the ranks of the “committed press” — the media that supported the government’s voice — had grown over the years, leaving very little space for the “critical press”.

Calling a spade a spade, Menon said: “Things are different now. Media now is neither free nor fearless. There are cases against journalists and arrests.”

She said the main weapon to bring the news media to its knees was stopping revenue from government advertising. “The revenue tap is being shut,” she said, referring to the government ads being refused to media organisations that spoke against the establishment.

The dirty picture

Mumbai Press Club Chairman Gurbir Singh, the head of the RedInk Awards Committee, flagged the increasing attacks and detention of journalists.

Quoting the latest Freedom of Press Index released by Reporters Without Borders (RWB), he said India had sunk eight notches to 150th position this year from 142 last year. “India is also seen as a very dangerous place for journalism with three-four journos being killed every year, according to the report,” he said.

In his welcome note, Gurbir Singh pointed out: “Hundreds of media professionals have lost their jobs in the past three years, and we have seen smaller companies being taken over by bigger ones…the time is not very far when perhaps the two As would control the media,” he said amidst peals of laughter from the audience.

The title sponsor for RedInk Awards 2022 is Zee Entertainment Enterprises (ZEEL), while Adani Group and Concept Communication are the gold sponsors. Indiabulls Housing, Aditya Birla Group, L&T Financial Services, Adfactors PR, Viacom18, and Glenmark Pharmaceuticals are associate sponsors.

REDINK AWARDS WINNERS – 2022

LIFETIME ACHIEVEMENT

TJS George

JOURNALIST OF THE YEAR

Om Gaur, Dainik Bhaskar Group

BUSINESS & ECONOMY

Print/Online: Anu Abraham, Mathrubhumi

Television/Video: Sonali Shinde, SAAM TV

CRIME

Print/Online : Angana Chakrabarti, The Print

Television/Video: Anurag Dwary, NDTV

ENTERTAINMENT & LIFESTYLE

Print/Online: Jane Borges, Mid-Day

ENVIRONMENT

Print/Online: Sushmita, The Caravan

Television/Video: Tridip Kanti Mandal & Dominic Savio Diengdoh, The Quint

HEALTH & WELLNESS

Print/Online, Aatreyee Dhar, Down to Earth

Television/Video, Barkha Dutt, Mojo Story

HUMAN RIGHTS

Print/Online, Kirti Dubey, BBC World

Television/Video, Aravind Venugopal, Malayala Manorama Online

POLITICS

Print/Online (Joint winners)

Vaibhav Walunj, Indie Journal

Siddharth Varadarajan, The Wire

Television/Video: Jugal Purohit, BBC News Hindi

SCIENCE & INNOVATION

Print/Online, Karishma Mehrotra, Scroll. in

SPORTS

Print/Online, Bhavya Dore, Mint Lounge

Television/Video, Vandna, BBC News Hindi

THE ARTS

Print/Online: Vinay Aravind, Fifty-Two

Television/Video: Namdev Anant Katkar, BBC World

The BIG PICTURE (Photo of the Year)

Winner: TP Sooraj, The New Indian Express

Runner up: Jinse Michael, Malayala Manorama

WOMEN’S EMPOWERMENT & GENDER EQUALITY

Print/Online: Sukanya Shanth, The Wire

Television/Video: Aishwarya S Iyer, The Quint.

Follow us