Justice M Nagaprasanna has said in his judgment on a petition filed by a 23-year-old advocate who was manhandled by the police.
A single-judge bench of Justice Pradeep Singh Yerur set aside the circulars issued by the Commissioner of Public Instructions and the Department of State Education. (Creative Commons)
When people begin to fear the state or its agents, there is tyranny, the Karnataka High Court has observed.
“When the state or its agents fear the people, there is liberty; when the people fear the state or its agents, there is tyranny,” Justice M Nagaprasanna has said in his judgement on a petition filed by a 23-year-old advocate from Dakshina Kannada district who was manhandled by the police.
He was also said a compensation of ₹3 lakh, which will be recovered from the erring police officers, will be paid to the petitioner.
Kuldeep, the advocate from Puthila village in Belthangady, had approached the high court after his complaint against Suthesh KP, a sub-inspector of police, was not registered. Even after a direction by the court, there was a delay in registering the FIR.
The high court in its judgement recently ordered the state’s Director General and Inspector General of Police to initiate a departmental inquiry against Suthesh “and his cohorts or any other officer, after identifying those officers who have indulged in the act of illegal arrest and alleged assault on the petitioner”.
The inquiry should be concluded within three months, the high court has directed.
The high court also ordered payment of ₹3 lakh compensation to Kuldeep which shall be recovered “from the salary of the officers found guilty in the departmental inquiry”.
Kuldeep had obtained a restraining order against his neighbours K Vasantha Gowda and his wife Bhavani from erecting a gate that would have prevented him from accessing his agricultural land. The police took no action on the court’s interim order and closed the complaint filed by Kuldeep.
On the same day, 2 December, 2022, Bhavani filed a complaint against Kuldeep for criminal trespass and theft, alleging he had stolen the gate.
The complaint was filed at 8.15 pm. But the police arrived at Kuldeep’s house at 8 pm and dragged him to the station without even allowing him to wear a shirt. His mother was also pushed aside.
He was produced before a magistrate the next day and was granted bail. He informed the magistrate about the ill-treatment and being beaten up by the police and tortured.
The magistrate recorded in the bail order to “issue intimation to his higher authority to take necessary action against the police officer for violation of the personal liberty of the accused”. Kuldeep spent the next two days in the hospital.
Kuldeep filed a complaint against sub-inspector Suthesh KP, but it was not registered. He approached the high court which sought a status report. It was only on 5 January, 2023, that the FIR was registered.
In its judgement, the high court said that the Superintendent of Police, Mangaluru would supervise the investigation against the sub-inspector.
The high court said that the arrest of Kuldeep was illegal as the offences alleged against him did not warrant it.
“No arrest should be made without a reasonable satisfaction reached after some investigation as to the genuineness and bona fide of the complaint/ information, as any arrest would deny a person of his liberty, which is a very serious matter, as arrest brings humiliation, curtails freedom and casts a scar forever.”
The high court concluded its judgement with a quote from Martin Luther King Junior.
“If an advocate could be treated in the manner of what he has been meted out in the case at hand, a common man will not be able to bear the burnt of repetition of such treatment. It is, therefore, the perpetrators of such illegality and violators of the law, cannot be let off the hook. They must be proceeded against both in a departmental inquiry, to fix accountability and under criminal law to deter any such iteration as, “injustice anywhere; is a threat to justice everywhere” MLK Jr.”
(Disclaimer: The headline, subheads, and intro of this report along with the photos may have been reworked by South First. The rest of the content is from a syndicated feed, and has been edited for style.)
May 14, 2024
May 14, 2024
May 02, 2024
May 01, 2024
Apr 25, 2024
Apr 23, 2024
