‘Politically vitiated narrative’, says Nirmala Sitharaman as Karnataka alleges fiscal injustice

Sitharaman said the 'system is well placed' and the government works according to Finance Commission recommendations.


Published Feb 05, 2024 | 2:15 PMUpdatedFeb 05, 2024 | 2:43 PM

Nirmala Sitharaman adressing the students

Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Monday, 5 February, came down heavily on allegations that the Union government is withholding funds meant for non-BJP governed states, saying it is a “politically-vitiated narrative” that “vested interests” are happy to go about saying.

Replying to a question by Congress leader Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury in the Lok Sabha on the Karnataka government’s claim that the Union government is not releasing funds due to it, Sitharaman said such a situation cannot happen as the “system is well placed” and the Union government works according to recommendations of the Finance Commission.

Also Read: CM says Karnataka lost over ₹45,000 crores due to Centre’s injustice

‘Politically-vitiated narrative’

“This apprehension that some states are being discriminated against is a politically-vitiated narrative which, I am sorry to say, vested interests are happy to go about saying,” she said during Question Hour.

Sitharaman added that no Union finance minister can play with the Finance Commission’s recommendations.

“This is just not a possibility that any finance minister can intervene to say that ‘I don’t like this state, stop payment’. No way. It can’t happen that way. The system is well placed,” she said.

There have been reports that Karnataka Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar said the Congress’ state unit — including all MLAs, MLCs and MPs — will protest against the Union government on 7 February in New Delhi for not allocating proper funds to the state in the interim Budget.

“Karnataka is the state that generates the second-highest tax in the country and it is sad that our state gets a setback every time. For the last five years, the BJP government has been ignoring Karnataka. This is unfair,” he had said.

‘No right to change rules’

The Union finance minister said she does not have any right to change the rules.

“I have no right to change the rules as per my whims and fancies… I have no role to play. In fact, I have to follow 100 percent,” she said.

“That is what I have done in my term. All finance ministers do that. Implement the recommendations of the Finance Commission. It is done without fear or favour,” she further said.

Sitharaman added Chowdhary claimed that she was working “politically” and said everything was hunky dory till six months ago.

“I want to say, till six months ago, all was hunky dory. What is going wrong now? Have you spent on items which you were not supposed to? I am not even questioning. Do spend it but don’t put the blame on me. Don’t put blame on the Union government as it goes by the book,” she said.

“If the expenditure is going in areas which it cannot sustain by your Budget, I am not answerable. Which government was there till six months ago is not my role to talk about. If it was hunky dory then and now it is not, introspect, please,” she added.

Also Read: ‘Will counter all allegations’: Vijayendra on Siddaramaiah’s remarks

Asks to consult Finance Commission

The finance minister said if there was an insinuation that she was withholding the money, everyone concerned should talk to the Finance Commission and tell their needs, requirements and status and let the commission take a call as it is a constitutional body.

Sitharaman said the Karnataka deputy chief minister had met her, conveyed to her the state’s issues and she heard him.

“I told him the matter of fact. I can’t do anything which the Finance Commission tells me not to do. Unless the Finance Commission asks me to do (something), I can’t do anything. I don’t have the discretion. Please don’t imagine that I have the discretion to play around with the Finance Commission’s recommendations. Please talk to the Finance Commission,” she said.

Sitharaman also said she was talking about the Finance Commission’s recommendations that she follows to the last word.

“I am not talking about anybody’s generosity. The Finance Commission gives recommendations, and I follow them. Now you suddenly say meet the state, I met the state. Then you said you are not doing anything, which I can’t,” she said.

Sitharaman said devolution of tax on direct tax matters happens according to the Finance Commission’s recommendations.

Explains GST

She said GST — particularly SGST (State GST) — is fully with the state as 100 per cent of it is collected by the state. The IGST is collected by the Union government as it involves a lot of inter-state payments.

Sitharaman added that it is also periodically reviewed by the GST Council because the states should get money in their hands — roughly, grossly, 50 percent is divided and then periodically readjusted to actual.

“So if a state were to get 41 (percent) and not 50 (percent), adjustment happens. If a state were to get 52 (percent), adjustment happens. Often, now and then, when the money is accumulated under the IGST, it is divided grossly at 50-50 to all states and gets reconciled over time when the data comes up,” she said.

Referring to the CGST (Central GST), the finance minister said it is divided on the advice of the Finance Commission, which determines the proportion, and all suggestions are accepted and implemented by the Centre.

This rate fixation has nothing to do with the Union government as how much should go to a state is determined by the Finance Commission.

“Does the Finance Commission sit in one place and take a call on it? No. It goes all over, meets with every state government, talks to them and only then (do) they submit the report,” she said.

Also Read: Kerala government hikes MSP for rubber by ₹10, agri sector gets ₹1,698 crore

Elaborates cess compensation

Replying to another question, Sitharaman said cess compensation is done on the basis of certificates provided by the accountant general of the state concerned.

“The moment they come with the accountant general’s certification, we pay them. In the case of Kerala, the accountant general’s certificate has been received for four years except the first quarter of 2022-23. Any payment that is made is done on the basis of the accountant general’s certificate. That is the principle on which the compensation cess is given,” she said.

The finance minister said Nagaland has not given the accountant general’s certificate for any year since 2017, Sikkim for three years, West Bengal for four years — it varies from state to state.

“The moment the claims along with the accountant general’s certificate comes, we release the compensation amount. We are not withholding any amount for any reason except this, ie the accountant general’s certificate,” she said.

(Disclaimer: The headline, subheads, and intro of this report along with the photos may have been reworked by South First. The rest of the content is from a syndicated feed, and has been edited for style.)