BJP-ruled Karnataka ranks higher in terms of number of hooch deaths, says Bihar deputy CM

The Bihar minister said this in a counterattack on the BJP which blamed the state government for a recent hooch tragedy.

Published Dec 15, 2022 | 5:07 PMUpdated Dec 15, 2022 | 5:07 PM

Karnataka hooch

Bihar Deputy Chief Minister and Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) leader Tejashwi Yadav said on Thursday, 15 December, that BJP-ruled Karnataka and Madhya Pradesh are the ranked higher than his state in terms of deaths relating to consumption of country-made alcohol (hooch).

Yadav made the comment in a counterattack on the BJP, which blamed the Bihar government for this week’s hooch tragedy in the state which killed 39 people and hospitalised many others.

The RJD leader claimed Madhya Pradesh and Karnataka stood at the top in terms of the number of hooch deaths while even Gujarat, a dry state, fared much worse than Bihar, which is in the spotlight over the Saran hooch tragedy.

“I am reading out from a statement given on the floor of Parliament by Union Minister of State for Home Nityanand Rai, who incidentally hails from Bihar, on July 19… BJP leaders here may do well to wear this on their chests,” remarked Yadav, who was visibly displeased over frequent disruptions of proceedings during the ongoing winter session.

“The MoS had made the statement in response to a query from MP Danish Ali who sought to know the number of deaths caused by the consumption of spurious liquor. The minister quoted NCRB data to submit that between 2016 and 2020, Madhya Pradesh accounted for the highest number of 1,214 hooch deaths, followed by Karnataka, where the number was 909. Both states are ruled by the BJP,” he said.

Also read: Karnataka sets up Cabinet panel on internal reservation

Another BJP-ruled state, Haryana, stood at number four. Even in Gujarat, a dry state from where Prime Minister Narendra Modi hails, the number of hooch deaths during the period was 50, while for Bihar it was only 21, Yadav said.

“BJP MLAs have been demanding Chief Minister Nitish Kumar’s resignation over the Saran hooch tragedy. Would they make similar demands with respect to chief ministers of states ruled by their own party?”

‘No moral right to raise the issue’

The RJD leader asserted that the BJP had “no moral right to raise the issue of violation of prohibition in Bihar” and recalled the alleged involvement of a brother of Ram Surat Rai, then a minister in the Cabinet, in the liquor trade, “which I had raised while I was in the Opposition”.

The young leader and son of former chief minister Lalu Prasad Yadav also sought to make light of the remark of his septuagenarian boss that “jo piyega woh marega (whoever drinks is doomed to die)” which has come under criticism from many quarters.

Political strategist-turned-activist Prashant Kishor had said at a press conference in Sheohar: “I challenge Nitish Kumar and his ministers to share their wisdom in any of the places where people have lost their lives because of hooch. They will get a taste of public anger.”

Yadav said, “What the chief minister is implying is that a wrong deed has unwarranted consequences. It is also not proper to link hooch deaths with prohibition. We must not lose sight of the fact that even in states where liquor is not banned, hooch tragedies do take place.”

Also read: Kalaburagi to change green as Hindutva hardliners see red

Asked about fresh demands for a “review” of the prohibition law in the wake of the spurt in hooch tragedies, Yadav said, “Let all those who hold such a view raise the matter inside the House. A legislative matter cannot be debated on the streets.”

“The fact is, the BJP is wary of its prospects in the 2024 Lok Sabha polls. It has little to offer, so it is indulging in all sorts of drama,” added Yadav.

(Disclaimer: Only the headline, subheads, and intro of this report along with the photos may have been reworked by South First. The rest of the content is from a syndicated feed)

Follow us