Wednesday, March 22, 2023
  • Login
The South First
Advertisement
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Videos
  • Dakshin Dialogues
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Videos
  • Dakshin Dialogues
No Result
View All Result
The South First
No Result
View All Result

Home » Opinion » Externalising federalism: Need a greater role for states

Externalising federalism: Need a greater role for states

Systemic changes that facilitate the ability of states to engage on external trade and investment issues in a more autonomous manner should be open for negotiations as we head towards delimitation in 2026.

Vijayalakshmi BalakrishnanbyVijayalakshmi Balakrishnan
Published:20/02/2023 1:36 pm
A A
A poster titled 'Invest in Tamil Nadu: India's only advanced manfucturing hub' at Davos 2023. As delimitation 2026 nears, states should be given more autonomy to engage in external trade and investment issues

A poster titled 'Invest in Tamil Nadu: India's only advanced manfucturing hub' at Davos 2023 (Guidance_TN/Twitter)

The Ministry of External Affairs has had a states division since 2014. A decade later, it is certainly time to consider states’ desks within India’s diplomatic missions

Davos 2023 saw competitive federalism, in spades. Punjab’s delegation was shepherded by Rajya Sabha MP Raghav Chadha, on his second outing at the gathering. As he explained to more than one television channel, everyone is trying to get a larger slice of the investment pudding on offer.

Tamil Nadu offered free Wi-Fi and south Indian food, also free, to those who dropped by at their space. Telangana and Maharashtra were not far behind.

Unease over 2026 delimitation in South India

The PM, an early votary of the concept of competitive federalism, has in recent months, sought to dial back the competitiveness.

In his Independence Day address last year, he spoke of “cooperative, competitive federalism”, underlining the cooperative nature of India’s federalism and eulogising the coming together of the country in the time of Covid. That shift in focus is related to the looming shadow of 2026, when the next delimitation of political constituencies has to be done.

Population growth in India has been uneven, with the northern states having grown faster than the rest of the country. In the context of India’s federal structure, this potentially means that one-third of all members of Lok Sabha would represent only three states — Uttar Pradesh, Bihar, and Bengal — a scenario that generates unease in many parts of the country, particularly south of the Vindhyas.

Learning from friends

“What do a Geraldton fisherman, a Perth university vice-chancellor, a Pilbara mining executive and a Margaret river winemaker, have in common?” That’s the opening sentence of a LinkedIn post, by the deputy premier of the state of Western Australia

The answer, they were part of a 100-people-plus trade and investment delegation that travelled to India. Western Australia’s delegation was on its way in summer 2022, a good five months before the India-Australia free trade agreement was inked.

Western Australia was the vanguard — the state led and the national government followed.

Australia and Canada, fellow members of the Commonwealth, have federal structures — with regular friction between the Centre and states, a scenario familiar to all Indians.

Both countries are also favoured destinations, for Indians, seeking home and fortune overseas. A principal reason is the quality of life provided to their citizens— something India today can only aspire for.

Despite their many similarities, institutionally, both countries have chosen to take a different path on trade and investment decision-making compared to India. Provinces in those countries have always had a greater external role, with the trade and investment offices of state governments dovetailing with national diplomacy.

Role of states

India’s states have taken steps, some boldly and others hesitantly.

Tamil Nadu has had an externally focussed investment promotion hub, Guidance, established in 1992.

Tamil Nadu – Rising and Shining at Davos, Switzerland.#TNatDavos2023 #wef23 #FutureOfAdvanced #InvestInTN #MakeInTN #ThriveInTN #Branding #Billboard #OOH pic.twitter.com/h0xBuQhi5A

— Guidance Tamil Nadu (@Guidance_TN) January 17, 2023

Neighbouring Kerala has had a department of non-resident Keralite affairs since 1996. Norka, was needed, as over 20 lakh Keralities, work overseas, and faced a series of small and large issues, both in the countries where they work and when they returned. Norka though was not directly mandated to facilitate trade and investment.

Dr Manmohan Singh, a long-term critic of India’s inward-looking trade policy, had established the Trade and Economic Relations Committee to refashion trade relationships.

During his state visit to Bangladesh in 2011, Singh’s delegation included the chief ministers of Bengal and the four Northeastern states that share a border with Bangladesh. That focus would be deepened by the next prime minister, who set up the states division within the MEA in his first year in office.

In May 2015, Prime Minister Narendra Modi signed a record 24 agreements with China, widening and deepening economic ties. Less noticed was the significance of an earlier visit by then Andhra Pradesh chief minister Chandrababu Naidu, who had visited China a few months prior, pegging his visit to the World Economic Forum-Asia gathering.

With a mandate to bring states and India’s external missions closer, to facilitate tourism, exports and investments, the states division is able to open doors and forge connections. This has benefitted many states, particularly in the Northeast, through a Northeast Round Table.

The larger states that have been externally focussed for a longer time have in-house expertise and significant networks, such as Guidance Tamil Nadu. These have been built over decades and could add depth to India’s economic diplomacy, if allowed to.

Reimagining 2026

Thinking and ideation on federalism have focused on the political, with representation being a potential friction-point. Delimitation in 2026, according to estimates, would mean that the number of seats available to the five southern states in Lok Sabha would drop from 129 to 108, reducing even further the role and influence of these states in national affairs.

Systemic changes, which facilitate the ability of states to engage on external trade and investment issues in a more autonomous manner, should be open for negotiations.

The Ministry of External Affairs has had a states division since 2014. A decade later, it is certainly time to consider states’ desks manned by state-professionals within India’s diplomatic missions. Davos, where the states led the charm offensive for investments, could become a metaphor for reimagining federalism within the idea of India.

(The author lives in a village in south India, and looks at the rest of India and the world from that perspective. She has been a journalist, a development worker, and a writer and podcaster over the years. She is author of ‘Growing Up And Away, Narratives of Indian Childhoods’. Email: baroquepodcast@gmail.com. These are the personal views of the author)

Don't miss our top stories!

We don’t spam! Read our privacy policy for more information.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Recommended For You

Smoke billowing from the fire-cracker unit (right); and District Collector M Aarthi at the scene. (Supplied)
Tamil Nadu

Tamil Nadu tragedy: 9 killed, 17 injured as blasts rip through Kancheepuram firecracker unit

March 22, 2023
Sexual Harassment Representational Image
Karnataka

Bengaluru: Police inspector suspended for sexual harassment of woman complainant

March 22, 2023
Deceased men while cleaning drain in Basavanakote village in Davanagere, Sathyappa (45) and Mylappa (42)
Karnataka

Davanagere village offers same ‘sweeper’ jobs to kin of 2 sanitation workers who died cleaning drains

March 22, 2023
(L) Kannada writer Yashwant Chittal; (R) a page of 'Digambara' in Chittal's handwriting
Karnataka

Digambara, Yashwant Chittal’s ‘writerly’ incomplete novel

March 22, 2023
BJP leader Baburao Chinchansur submitted his resignation from the legislative council on Monday. (supplied)
Karnataka

Legislators, caste leaders quit BJP ahead of Karnataka polls. What is the impact on the ground?

March 22, 2023
Padma Lakshmi (centre) after enrolling as a lawyer at an event held at Kerala High Court. (Supplied)
Kerala

Interview: Meet transwoman Padma Lakshmi, the 1st transgender lawyer of Kerala

March 22, 2023

Top Stories

Smoke billowing from the fire-cracker unit (right); and District Collector M Aarthi at the scene. (Supplied)

Tamil Nadu tragedy: 9 killed, 17 injured as blasts rip through Kancheepuram firecracker unit

March 22, 2023
Deceased men while cleaning drain in Basavanakote village in Davanagere, Sathyappa (45) and Mylappa (42)

Davanagere village offers same ‘sweeper’ jobs to kin of 2 sanitation workers who died cleaning drains

March 22, 2023
BJP leader Baburao Chinchansur submitted his resignation from the legislative council on Monday. (supplied)

Legislators, caste leaders quit BJP ahead of Karnataka polls. What is the impact on the ground?

March 22, 2023

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive daily updates direct to your inbox.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Like and Follow

Follow @TheSouthfirst

Latest

On 19 March, a case was registered against Mallanna for defamatory comments against K Kavitha and KT Rama Rao. (Facebook)

Telangana YouTuber Teenmar Mallanna arrested for ‘abduction’, ‘assault’ of 2 police personnel

March 22, 2023
Telangana Congress leaders with Governor. (Twitter)

TSPSC paper leak: Revanth Reddy meets Governor, demands dissolution of TSPSC

March 22, 2023
Smoke billowing from the fire-cracker unit (right); and District Collector M Aarthi at the scene. (Supplied)

Tamil Nadu tragedy: 9 killed, 17 injured as blasts rip through Kancheepuram firecracker unit

March 22, 2023
The South First

CATEGORIES

  • News
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Featured
  • Health & Wellness
  • Andhra Pradesh
  • Karnataka
  • Kerala
  • Tamil Nadu
  • Telangana

PAGES

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2023 The South First

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Health & Wellness
  • Dakshin Dialogues
  • Videos

© 2023 The South First

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our