Synopsis: The Kerala High Court has dismissed a petition filed by advocate TB Mini, who represented the survivor in the 2017 actor assault case, seeking contempt proceedings against trial court judge Honey M Varghese for alleged disparaging remarks against her during the trial. The controversy began when the trial judge reportedly described Mini as an ‘absent lawyer’, claiming that she had attended court for fewer than 10 days and had often been found sleeping in the courtroom.
The Kerala High Court on Tuesday, 17 November, dismissed a petition filed by advocate TB Mini, who represented the survivor in the 2017 actor assault case, seeking contempt proceedings against trial court judge Honey M Varghese for alleged disparaging remarks against her during the trial.
Justice PV Kunhikrishnan pronounced the verdict. A copy of the order is awaited.
Judge Honey M Varghese
The controversy began when the trial judge reportedly described Mini as an ‘absent lawyer’, claiming that she had attended court for fewer than 10 days and had often been found sleeping in the courtroom. The remarks triggered widespread criticism and a social media campaign against the advocate.
Mini said the remarks had damaged her professional reputation and that the online campaign had caused considerable mental distress to the survivor.
She maintained that she had attended the proceedings on more than 200 days and that the remarks were unnecessary and had no bearing on the adjudication of the case.
Advocate TB Mini
She subsequently lodged a complaint before the High Court’s Administrative Committee. She also approached the Advocate General seeking consent to initiate contempt proceedings. However, the Advocate General’s office informed her that the matter did not fall within the scope of contempt of court.
Mini then moved the High Court seeking the initiation of suo motu contempt proceedings against Justice Varghese. In her petition, Mini also sought directions to address the remarks and the removal of media reports carrying them.
During an earlier hearing, the High Court had orally questioned whether remarks made by a trial judge that did not form part of the judicial record could be expunged.
(Edited by Dese Gowda with inputs from Dileep V Kumar)