Complaints that Chief Minister VD Satheesan was taking key decisions without consulting his Cabinet colleagues, repeatedly raised by the Opposition over the past six months, have now surfaced within the UDF government itself.
The differences reportedly came to a head at a Cabinet meeting on Wednesday as the government completed six months in office, with ministers openly questioning the Chief Minister over the manner in which appointments to statutory bodies and boards were being finalised.
The unusually sharp exchange began when Satheesan placed before the Cabinet a list of proposed members to the Public Service Commission (PSC).
Questions over appointments to boards
A.P. Anil Kumar, Revenue Minister and KPCC working president, objected, saying the names had been finalised without prior discussion with other ministers.
The Chief Minister defended the move, saying the appointments had to be made urgently.
Anil Kumar then pointed out that there had also been no collective discussion on appointments to the Guruvayur Devaswom Board.
The exchange brought out wider discontent among ministers over what they described as the absence of consultation on important decisions.
The meeting, marked by lengthy deliberations and exchanges, it’s learnt, lasted around two-and-a-half hours.
Dewasom Minister K. Muraleedharan intervened to clarify that the Guruvayur Devaswom list had been prepared in consultation with him.
But his explanation did not end the objections.
‘Unaware of important developments’
Electricity Minister and KPCC president Sunny Joseph reportedly questioned how several decisions were being taken without his knowledge, observing that even in his capacity as KPCC president, he remained unaware of important developments.
Satheesan maintained that certain matters required immediate decisions and could not be held up by prolonged consultations.
However, the complaints continued, with RSP leader and minister Shibu Baby John pointing out that his party was not receiving adequate representation in appointments to boards and corporations.
As the impasse continues, it’s learnt that senior ministers Ramesh Chennithala and P K Kunjalikutty later intervened and work out a consensus formula with their Cabinet colleagues.
Guruvayur Devaswom Board- a trigger
The proposed appointments to the Guruvayur Devaswom Board emerged as the immediate trigger for the confrontation.
While the Chief Minister’s Office maintained that the list had been prepared by the Devaswom Minister’s office, other ministers reportedly complained that names were being finalised at the CMO without adequate consultation.
Muraleedharan, however, stood by Satheesan, maintaining that the decision had been taken after discussions with the Chief Minister.
The disagreement has brought into focus competing claims over how the appointments were processed and the extent of consultation within the Cabinet.
There are currently two vacancies in the general category and one for an employees’ representative on the Devaswom Board.
The names understood to have been proposed are Congress leaders C.V. Balachandran and Shivan Paliath for the general category, and P. Abhilash as the employees’ representative.
Minister Muraleedharan later acknowledged that objections had been raised over the appointments.
He said the formal order would be issued after it was signed by the Hindu ministers and was expected either today or the following day, immediately after the Chief Minister returned from New Delhi.
Asked how many ministers would sign the order, he declined to disclose details, saying he could not reveal Cabinet secrets.
Objections from inside
The latest episode has given fresh currency to the Opposition’s allegations that the Cabinet was not functioning through collective deliberation and that the Chief Minister was taking decisions on his own.
While the government had so far faced such criticism from outside, the objections voiced by ministers at the meeting suggest that concerns over consultation and the distribution of political positions have also become an issue within the ruling front.
The dispute is not confined to the Guruvayur appointments.
Anil Kumar’s objection over the PSC list, Sunny Joseph’s complaint about being kept out of the loop and Shibu Baby John’s concern over the RSP’s share in board and corporation positions point to a broader unease among coalition partners and ministers.
Coming at the six-month mark of the UDF government, the Cabinet exchange has brought the question of collective decision-making into sharper focus.
(Edited by Sumavarsha, with inputs from Dileep V Kumar)