Monday, June 5, 2023
  • Login
The South First
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Videos
  • Karnataka Elections 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment
  • Opinion
  • Health
  • Videos
  • Karnataka Elections 2023
No Result
View All Result
The South First
No Result
View All Result

Home » Kerala » Coca-Cola’s offer to hand over its land, building to Kerala government brings the fizz back to Plachimada agitation

Coca-Cola’s offer to hand over its land, building to Kerala government brings the fizz back to Plachimada agitation

Almost 20 years after its bottling plant was shut, the living victims of Plachimada feel Coke and the state are jointly trying to cheat them.

K A ShajibyK A Shaji
Published:23/04/2023 10:00 am
A A
Plachimada antiCoca-Cola protest Coke

Drinking water scarcity continues to haunt the once water-abundant Plachimada. (Madhuraj)

Coca-Cola Revives and Sustains, screamed the slogan coined in 1905. More than a century later, the people of Plachimada in Kerala’s Palakkad district disagree.

The global beverages giant has come a long way since 1905 to arrive at the slogan, Be Open Like Never Before, in 2020. However, this was not the only slogan Coke had that year.

It did open up and offered to hand over its 35 acres at Perumatty in Plachimada to the Kerala government. The Plachimada villagers, however, are sceptical.

Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages Pvt Ltd (HCCBPL) made the offer almost two decades after it was forced to wind up its bottling plant operations in Kerala.

The offer, however, does not ameliorate the sufferings of Plachimada residents like that of septuagenarian tribal woman Kanniammal. She treads long distances to collect water for the daily requirements of her family.

Incidentally, the 35 acres were originally agriculture fields where paddy, groundnuts and vegetables grew.

Upended lives

A trip down memory lane takes Kanniammal from the Ervala community to a water-sufficient Plachimada hamlet, where almost all houses had wells that provided water even during peak summer.

Plachimada
The continuing struggle by the Plachimada victims. (Madhuraj)

And there were clean brooks and streams that merrily gurgled downstream throughout the year.

Then came Coca-Cola and its massive bottling unit in 2000.

After the fast-moving consumer goods major had set up its plant, the residents of Plachimada found their wells drying up and their agriculture fields turning toxic.

Sensing the danger involved, people rose in protest, a protest which received support from across the globe. Following the uncompromising agitation, and based on an order by the Kerala State Pollution Control Board, Coca-Cola shut the plant in March 2004.

In July 2017, the company informed the Supreme Court that it did not plan to reopen the bottling unit.

However, four years later in 2021, the state government opened the plant to set up a temporary Covid-19 treatment centre.

Also read: All about a stir that fine-tuned the non-violence movement

Toxic, water-guzzling plant

“The month of March marked the 19th year of Coca-Cola leaving Kerala,” Kanniammal recalled.

Plachimada
Medha Patkar leads the Plachimada agitation in 2003. (Madhuraj)

“But the whole village and its surrounding areas are still suffering from the plant’s excessive drawing of groundwater and irresponsible disposal of sludge,” the septuagenarian told South First.

While operational, the plant used to draw 5,00,000 litres of water daily — four litres each for one litre of the carbonated drink.

“The water scarcity in our locality is turning acute by each passing year, and our livelihoods have been crippled beyond repair,” she added.

The plant also distributed waste sludge free as fertiliser to farmers. In 2003, a BBC correspondent collected samples of the sludge and sent them to a lab at the University of Exeter in the UK.

The test result was shocking: The sludge contained unacceptably high levels of cadmium and lead. Cadmium is a carcinogen, while lead could adversely affect the nervous system.

“The area’s farming industry has been devastated, and jobs, as well as the health of the local people, have been put at risk,” John Waite said in BBC Radio 4’s Face the Facts programme while reading out the findings made by the Exeter scientists.

Also read: Environmentalist’s death note details state failure to protect Ghats

An act of atonement… 

A dilapidated thatched shed stands by the imposing closed gates of the bottling plant. The shed was once the office of the Coca-Cola Virudha Janakeeya Samara Samithy (Anti-Coca-Cola Peoples Struggle Committee).

Plachimada
A protest in front of the Coca-Cola factory in Plachimada. (Madhuraj)

Canadian rights activist Maude Barlow and Finland’s former minister Satu Hassi were among the world leaders who had addressed the protesters at this venue.

Plachimada and its protracted agitation against the aerated drinks major are now back in the news again.

On April 21, Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan received a letter from Juan Pablo Rodriguez, the CEO of HCCBPL.

The letter expressed the company’s willingness to hand over the 35 acres it had acquired from people in Plachimada to the state government.

The government would also get the building complex where the bottling unit had functioned.

Additionally, the company promised to provide technical assistance free of cost if the government sets up a demo farm, with farmers as its major stakeholders.

Incidentally, a high-power committee set up by the state government estimated that the plant had caused damages to the tune of ₹216.26 crore. No compensation has been paid so far.

Also read: Greens worried as K’taka gets Western Ghats ESA tag put on hold

Or a deft move to shun responsibility?

According to Kerala’s Minister for Power and local MLA K Krishnankutty, the land purchased by the company using its funds would be handed over free of cost to the government.

Plachimada
The thee-day World Water Congress held in Plachimada in 2004 to express solidarity with the local community. (Madhuraj)

He said the government is planning to utilise the property for the benefit of the local farmers. The minister explained that a farmer-oriented project employing local women and former employees of the company is on the cards.

However, the living victims of groundwater exploitation in Plachimada felt the move is yet another attempt by the aerated drinks major to shortchange them. They also expressed doubts over the government’s intentions.

“The company is bound to give us compensation to the tune of ₹216 crore for crippling us and our lands. An expert committee constituted by the state government decided the compensation,” Arumukhan Pathichira of the Plachimada Solidarity Committee told South First.

He felt that a concerted effort is on to avoid paying the compensation.

“Now, the government and the company are jointly trying to shy away from the responsibility of paying the compensation through this gimmick. We will not allow this move,” he asserted.

Also read: Fuming Church makes LDF government scramble for solutions

Birth and death of a Bill 

Pathichira added that the Solidarity Committee has been continuously demanding compensation. “The ruling LDF government has done nothing to revive the now-defunct Plachimada Compensation Bill,” he pointed out.

Plachimada
The Plachimada agitation committee office. (Madhuraj)

The Kerala Assembly unanimously passed the Plachimada Coca-Cola Victims’ Relief and Compensation Claims Special Tribunal Bill on 24 February, 2011. The Bill was to ensure compensation for the residents of Plachimada village.

However, the then President Pranab Mukherjee returned the Bill without giving assent on 1 February, 2016. “The President is pleased to withhold assent,” the Rashtrapati Bhavan said in a communique.

The Bill was denied assent on the recommendation of the Union Home Ministry, which consulted other ministries and HCCBPL. Coca-Cola’s stand has been that the Bill is not legally valid, since the National Green Tribunal (NGT) has been established.

Pathichira alleged that the state government is now trying to help Coke to shun legal obligations.

“The world sat up and took note of Plachimada when the mighty Coca-Cola accepted defeat. We will not allow the company to cheat us by conspiring with the government,”  Vilayodi Venugopal, an agriculture worker, who became the face of the agitation, said.

“Despite its promise to reintroduce the Bill in the Kerala state Assembly, the LDF government is now attempting to settle the issue forever by working out a compromise formula,” Venugopal told South First.

The formula, he felt, would favour Coke. “Those who were once eloquent about our miseries have now become silent and inactive,” he lamented.

Incidentally, after taking charge as the chief minister in 2016, Pinarayi Vijayan promised to relook at and reintroduce the Bill. But he didn’t.

Also read: Erosion not because of Vizhinjam, draft White Paper tells NGT

Long-lasting damage 

“It is true that the factory has been shut since 2004. But the alarming groundwater depletion it had caused continues to haunt us,” another Plachimada protester Arumughan said.

Plachimada
People from different walks of like joined the Plachimada protesters. (Madhuraj)

“Before the bottling plant was established, we had enough water from our wells, streams and rivulets,” he recalled with a tinge of nostalgia.

Incidentally, after the government Primary Health Centre confirmed independent reports that the water in and around Plachimada was unfit for human conception, Coca-Cola admitted that there was an issue with the water.

But it was unrelated to its activities, Coke said.

The firm offered to provide drinking water via tankers and to initiate rainwater harvesting programmes at the factory and in the community.

There are about 2,000 families in the predominantly tribal region of Plachimada, and agriculture is their mainstay.

“Apart from making Coca-Cola pay a compensation of ₹216 crore for crippling life at Perumatty, the Bill also had provisions for initiating action against the company for draining groundwater,” local tribal activist Neelippara Mariyappan said.

“It also had envisaged the prosecution of the company’s top executives under the provisions of preventing atrocities against Dalits and tribal people. But all major political fronts in Kerala failed us,” he added.

Also read: Despondency in Vizhinjam as Latin Catholic Church backs down

Minister’s wrong move

On 22 April, 2002, more than 1,300 people marched to the Coca-Cola plant and laid siege to it. The protest was the result of the indiscriminate exploitation of natural resources.

Protest_by_Plachimada_people
Coca-Cola was forced to concede defeat as the protesters refused to blink. (Sourced)

“The water table fell drastically, and the leftover sources became unusable. Even today, the well water in Vijayanagar Colony, Plachimada Colony, Rajunagar, Velur, Madhavamotharpathy, Kochikadu, and Thotichipathy, and surrounding villages tastes sour,” Venugopal said.

He said the defunct Bill had promised a special tribunal for the speedy adjudication of disputes and recovery of compensation for the poor, landless victims of Coca-Cola.

“The state Assembly had passed the Bill unanimously when VS Achuthanandan was the chief minister. Several legal luminaries thought there was no need to obtain the President’s consent and that the state government could promulgate it,” said S Faizi.

Faizi was the technical member of the Plachimada High Power Committee constituted by the state government to look into the damage caused by the company.

“But the then law minister M Vijayakumar had by then forwarded the Bill to the Union Home Ministry for the President’s assent without taking his Cabinet colleagues or experts into confidence,” he alleged.

“It is high time that the government and Opposition parties in Kerala reintroduced the Bill after deleting controversial portions, if any. But sadly, the government is playing second fiddle to the FMCG major,” he said.

Also read: Houseboats, enchanting views hide impending death of Vembanad

Unanswered questions

Faizi also mentioned the Union Home Ministry’s “flawed” observation that the Bill conflicted with the NGT Act. He said the NGT could accept petitions for compensation in cases only up to five-and-a-half years before its inception.

“The NGT came into existence only in May 2011. The groundwater exploitation and toxic contamination caused by the company at Plachimada occurred during 2000-2004,” he told South First.

“The NDA government at the Centre cheated us by succumbing to the pressure of the multinational giant and forcing the President to return the Bill,” Vijayan Amabalakkad, a leader of the committee that had headed the anti-Coca-Cola struggle, said.

“Both the LDF and UDF have not responded to our demand to re-enact the legislation,” he added.

“The anti-Coke struggle posed several questions to the civil society and the political-judicial systems of the country. They are related to the ownership of groundwater and other natural resources,” Faizi said.

“The company was established, ignoring objections from the local panchayat. Its warnings were often ignored and overruled. In an agrarian society, its water resources were diverted for industrial use. Now, is the government protecting the polluter from paying up,” Faizi asked.

Faizi’s questions remain unanswered even three years after Coke had coined another slogan: Together Tastes Better.

Recommended For You

As Telangana tops CSE report in overall performance know where rest of South states finished, World Environment Day
News

As Telangana tops CSE report in environment performance, know where other South states stand

June 5, 2023
Drug ban India
Health

India cites therapeutic irrelevance and risks to ban 14 fixed-dose combination medicines used for cough, fever, and infections

June 5, 2023
Sand artist Sudarshan Pattnaik pays tribute to those who died in the Balasore train accident in Odisha.
Politics

Triple-train accident: Odisha grapples with challenge of identifying the dead; 88 identified so far

June 4, 2023
KCR Dharani portal
News

Dump Congress leaders in the Bay of Bengal for criticising Dharani portal, says KCR

June 4, 2023
Arrests hit half-century in TSPSC paper leak case as SIT to identify candidates wearing Bluetooth earpieces
News

TSPSC paper leak case: SIT to identify candidates who wore Bluetooth earpieces; arrests hit half-century

June 4, 2023
BJP Telangana president Bandi Sanjay.
News

Bandi Sanjay dismisses speculations of TDP-BJP alliance, despite Chandrababu Naidu-Amit Shah meeting

June 4, 2023

Top Stories

As Telangana tops CSE report in overall performance know where rest of South states finished, World Environment Day

As Telangana tops CSE report in environment performance, know where other South states stand

June 5, 2023
Sand artist Sudarshan Pattnaik pays tribute to those who died in the Balasore train accident in Odisha.

Triple-train accident: Odisha grapples with challenge of identifying the dead; 88 identified so far

June 4, 2023
Arrests hit half-century in TSPSC paper leak case as SIT to identify candidates wearing Bluetooth earpieces

TSPSC paper leak case: SIT to identify candidates who wore Bluetooth earpieces; arrests hit half-century

June 4, 2023

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive daily updates direct to your inbox.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Like and Follow

Follow @TheSouthfirst

Latest

As Telangana tops CSE report in overall performance know where rest of South states finished, World Environment Day

As Telangana tops CSE report in environment performance, know where other South states stand

June 5, 2023
Drug ban India

India cites therapeutic irrelevance and risks to ban 14 fixed-dose combination medicines used for cough, fever, and infections

June 5, 2023
Sand artist Sudarshan Pattnaik pays tribute to those who died in the Balasore train accident in Odisha.

Triple-train accident: Odisha grapples with challenge of identifying the dead; 88 identified so far

June 4, 2023
The South First

CATEGORIES

  • News
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Featured
  • Health & Wellness
  • Andhra Pradesh
  • Karnataka
  • Kerala
  • Tamil Nadu
  • Telangana

PAGES

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2023 The South First

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Health & Wellness
  • Karnataka Elections 2023
  • Dakshin Dialogues
  • Videos

© 2023 The South First

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our