Monday, October 2, 2023
  • Login
The South First
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
    • National
  • Entertainment
    • Kannada
    • Malayalam
    • Tamil
    • Telugu
    • Reviews
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Videos
    • Lifestyle
  • More
    • Opinion
    • In The News
    • Dakshin Dialogues
    • Cartoons
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
    • National
  • Entertainment
    • Kannada
    • Malayalam
    • Tamil
    • Telugu
    • Reviews
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Videos
    • Lifestyle
  • More
    • Opinion
    • In The News
    • Dakshin Dialogues
    • Cartoons
No Result
View All Result
The South First
No Result
View All Result
Jagananna Arogya Suraksha Jagananna Arogya Suraksha Jagananna Arogya Suraksha

Home » Health » Karnataka Administrative Reforms Commission recommends ban on private practice by government doctors

Karnataka Administrative Reforms Commission recommends ban on private practice by government doctors

Mixed response from medicos to TM Vijay Bhaskar-headed commission's recommendation to ban private practice.

Chetana BelagerebyChetana Belagere
Published:04/02/2023 9:02 am
A A
Karnataka ban on private practice by doctors

Karnataka Administration Reforms Commission, headed by TM Vijay Bhaskar, submitted its report to Chief Minister Basavaraj Bommai. (Supplied)

To ban or not to ban private practice by government doctors? The question is back in play in Karnataka with a government-appointed commission rooting for a ban.

The Karnataka Administrative Reforms Commission, headed by former chief secretary TM Vijay Bhaskar, has observed that a large number of doctors in government health centres indulge in private practice after official duty hours and has recommended a “ban (on) private practice by government doctors in all departments”.

The commission — which submitted its recommendations to the government on Friday, 3 February — noted that the ban on private practice will help the state start evening Out Patient Departments (OPDs) in government hospitals.

“If doctors are barred from the private practice they may be more willing to put in extra hours to make up for vacant posts. It would also be easier to ensure their attendance in government hospitals during duty hours if there is no pull of private practice,” the commission’s report stated.

Backing a ban

The commission noted that the state government gives an option to medical doctors to take up private practice or receive a Non Practising Allowance (NPA). But as there are a large number of corporate hospitals and nursing homes in urban areas, there are ample opportunities for government doctors to take up private practice.

Arguing against private practice, the commission said there were an adequate number of doctors in Karnataka — in fact, better than the norms set by WHO — and there are enough private doctors and private medical establishments to cater to the public that can afford to pay private fees.

“So far, about 20 States have banned private practice. It is also banned in GoI (Government of India) medical institutes and in Central Health Service Rules. It is therefore recommended that Government of Karnataka consider banning private practice by all Government doctors of all departments in the interest of ensuring better medical care to patients in Government hospitals. DME and HFW department may move a proposal in this regard,” it said.

Also, similarly placed government teachers and lecturers are barred from taking private tuitions, the commission noted.

Read This: Why is K’taka checking C-section deliveries in district hospitals?

What do doctors say?

When South First spoke to few government doctors, there were mixed responses to the commission’s recommendation.

One senior doctor at one of the reputed medical colleges in Bengaluru said the issue of banning private practice has been discussed time and again, but it has never been implemented.

“The main objective is to prevent government doctors from taking up private practice during office hours. This can be ensured by regular/surprise checks and appropriate punishments,” the senior doctor said.

He contended that banning private practice by experienced government doctors will affect a lot of the rural population and inhabitants of smaller towns — as they will have to seek medical advice from private doctors.

Also Read: Karnataka identifies land for new private medical colleges

“It is not fair to restrict the optimal utilisation of a medical professional’s expertise. If they practice, it will help the common man as they will be available once the OPDs in the government set-up closes and emergency services are non-existent at PHCs and sub-centre levels,” he added.

However, another doctor, a nephrologist from one of the district hospitals, said government patients would definitely benefit from the move.

“The government is planning evening practice in government hospitals by giving incentives to doctors. This will be good for government doctors. This is a win-win situation for both government doctors and patients coming to government hospitals,” he said.

However, Dr Manjunath CN, director, Jayadeva Institute of Cardiovascular Disease Research Hospital, said this experiment has been tried many times in many states, ultimately it is going to be a futile exercise.

He called it a double-edged decision. According to him, many specialists might opt to exit from government hospitals, resulting in shortage of faculty, especially in rural, semi-urban and district-level hospitals, thus affecting patient care.

He argued for the creation of a conducive working environment with proper facilities and leadership so that quality and timely treatment is provided within working hours.

“Decentralisation and delegation within hospitals is equally important. Attendance does not necessarily mean attention,” he added.

Recommended For You

File photo of Trevor Noah.
Entertainment

Days after cancelling Bengaluru show, Trevor Noah jokes about its venue and acoustics in Mumbai

October 2, 2023
Tamil Nadu Health Minister Ma Subramanian (third left) handing over a cheque to one of the injured passengers at the Coonoor Government Hospital on Sunday. (X)
In The News

As Coonoor bus tragedy toll rises to 9, TN health minister hands over ₹50,000 each to the injured

October 1, 2023
JDS - BJP alliance Lok Sabha elections Kumaraswamy CM Ibrahim
In The News

JD(S) turmoil: Karnataka president CM Ibrahim voices dissent over BJP alliance

October 1, 2023
Criticizing the ruling BRS, the Prime Minister said that ‘false promises’ regarding loan waivers were made to farmers, which led to suicides. (Supplied)
News

Telangana government is a car controlled by someone else, says PM Modi in Mahbubnagar

October 1, 2023
KTR
In The News

BRS is a family of 4 crore Telangana people with KCR as its head, says KTR in response to PM Modi jibe

October 1, 2023
File photo of the Cauvery river.
In The News

Cauvery dispute: Karnataka files review petition before CWMA even as increased inflow brings respite

October 1, 2023
apdc advt

Top Stories

Criticizing the ruling BRS, the Prime Minister said that ‘false promises’ regarding loan waivers were made to farmers, which led to suicides. (Supplied)

Telangana government is a car controlled by someone else, says PM Modi in Mahbubnagar

October 1, 2023
Modi

Ahead of his Nizamabad visit, PM Modi announces Turmeric Board to win over Telangana farmers

October 1, 2023
An aerial view of kanathallur village nestled on top of Western Ghats in Idukki. Photo: Kerala Tourism.

Welcome to little-known Kanthalloor in Kerala, which won Union government golden award for best rural tourism project

October 1, 2023

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Sign Up For Our Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receive daily updates direct to your inbox.

Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription.

Like and Follow

Follow @TheSouthfirst

Latest

File photo of Trevor Noah.

Days after cancelling Bengaluru show, Trevor Noah jokes about its venue and acoustics in Mumbai

October 2, 2023
Tamil Nadu Health Minister Ma Subramanian (third left) handing over a cheque to one of the injured passengers at the Coonoor Government Hospital on Sunday. (X)

As Coonoor bus tragedy toll rises to 9, TN health minister hands over ₹50,000 each to the injured

October 1, 2023
JDS - BJP alliance Lok Sabha elections Kumaraswamy CM Ibrahim

JD(S) turmoil: Karnataka president CM Ibrahim voices dissent over BJP alliance

October 1, 2023
The South First

CATEGORIES

  • News
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Entertainment & Culture
  • Featured
  • Health & Wellness
  • Andhra Pradesh
  • Karnataka
  • Kerala
  • Tamil Nadu
  • Telangana

PAGES

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

© 2023 The South First

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • States
    • Andhra Pradesh
    • Karnataka
    • Kerala
    • Tamil Nadu
    • Telangana
  • Politics
    • Behind the News
    • National
  • Entertainment & Culture
    • Kannada
    • Malayalam
    • Tamil
    • Telugu
    • Reviews
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Health & Wellness
  • Lifestyle
  • In The News
  • Cartoons
  • Dakshin Dialogues
  • Videos
    • Lifestyle

© 2023 The South First

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used.