Menu

Is Karthik Subbaraj’s ‘Dorothy’ a fairy tale? It certainly checks off its prerequisites

Dorothy’s fairytale-like ending is its strongest point, as it uses the familiarity audiences have with tropes like the true-love’s kiss to challenge their ideological expectations of romantic fulfilment.

Published Nov 19, 2026 | 4:41 PM ⚊ Updated Nov 19, 2026 | 4:42 PM

Dorothy movie poster
Make Us Your Preferred Source on Google

Synopsis: Karthik Subbaraj’s ‘Dorothy’ recalls Walt Disney’s ‘Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs’. But Snow White’s distress differs starkly from Dorothy’s. While the Disney princess is passive and vulnerable, her distress maintains an archetypal womanhood. Dorothy, however, practices Bruce Lee-inspired martial arts, protects herself against men who try to violate her, and is quick-witted in unfamiliar situations. Her distress stems from being a woman in a masculine world, forced to exist in its crevices. Both damsels therefore tell a different story of distress and survival.

A young woman finds herself in a precarious situation, and the film tells her tale of redemption. Dorothy, however, opened the floodgates by reimagining a fairy tale and questioning the conventions that define the genre. Her story becomes that of an everywoman navigating a world where her very existence threatens a ruthless patriarch’s power. It’s a familiar world of caste hierarchy, obsession and betrayal, presented through the perspective of Dorothy, a woman whose place was not secure within the long-established templates of fairy tales.

One tale that comes to mind is Walt Disney’s Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937). Dorothy’s journey as a transgender woman begins with her performance as a hypermasculine male figure as a self-preservation method, leading up to her claiming her true identity as a woman, inside and out, through ritual and celebration. The film’s plot overlaps with Snow White’s tropes and ingeniously extends them into a recognisable narrative.

Also Read: Caste, colour, and anti-caste politics in mainstream cinema

Damsels and Distress

Two protagonists drive the stories: Snow White and Dorothy. In the former, the central premise pits two women against each other. The evil queen discovers the young princess’s beauty, magically revealed to her through an enslaved person trapped in a mirror. This fear leads her to summon a huntsman, instructing him to lead the princess to the forest, where he is to kill her and bring back her heart as proof of murder.

Mirrors play an important, subject-defining role in the film as Subbu’s inner femininity is always visible through mirrors.

Mirrors play an important, subject-defining role in the film as Subbu’s inner femininity is always visible through mirrors.

The huntsman attempts to complete his task but is moved by the princess’ innocence and asks her to flee and not return. Back in the palace, the huntsman presents the heart of a pig to convince the queen of the princess’ demise. Meanwhile, deep in the forest, the princess is among a chosen family of seven dwarfs who are miners. The queen soon finds out the truth, eventually poisons the young princess, and she falls into a death-like sleep. The story ends with her prince breaking her spell with a true-love’s kiss, after which they live happily ever after.

Then there is Dorothy. We meet a child, Subbu, who carries a mental checklist of what it means to be a man to make sure she performs convincingly as masculine, following Judith Butler’s theorisation of gender performativity. Subbu’s father, Whistle Veerayya, is a feudal gangster-patriarch with strict ideals of caste purity, family honour, and masculinity. His house is emblematic of hypermasculinity in its architecture and residents, and any trace of femininity ceases to exist in this domestic space. He is the villain in Subbu’s story, as she mentions time and again.

Subbu, like Snow White, has an animal companion, a pet rooster and sits by a death-loomed wishing well, calling out to her deceased mother, sister, and dear friend and wishing them to come back. She later flees to safeguard herself and is adopted by a family of seven transgender women who help her become the picture of womanhood through the nirvaanam ritual.

Mirrors play an important, subject-defining role in the film as Subbu’s inner femininity is always visible through mirrors. At times, she playfully checks herself out after a bath. During the climax, the haunting image of her shaving off her beard and donning a saree is reflected in a mirror, ultimately to be replaced by a celebratory vision of her as Dorothy in a mirror. Here she receives the divine right of existence through Bahuchara Mata’s intercession. No other male character is caught looking in a mirror, except Karthi, who is getting ready to go and find her toward the end.

Despite these similarities, Snow White’s distress differs starkly from Dorothy’s. While the Disney princess is passive and vulnerable, her distress serves to maintain an archetypal womanhood. Dorothy, however, practices Bruce Lee-inspired martial arts, protects herself against men who try to violate her, and is quick-witted in unfamiliar situations. Her distress stems from being a woman in a masculine world, forced to exist in its crevices. Both damsels therefore tell a different story of distress and survival.

Also Read: Deepavali sparks the caste conversation in Tamil cinema

The hunters and their prey

As a child, Karthi learns about masculinity through Subbu’s checklist, ultimately becoming rowdy himself. However, from his very first interaction with Whistle, he is marginalised based on his caste identity. Karthi becomes the huntsman when Whistle wants Dorothy killed for her transgressive display of femininity; an excess that would be associated with his masculine family honour.

As proof, Whistle wants a not-yet-named Dorothy’s body back, along with the family amulet, to contain the narrative. The huntsman thus sets out to kill his childhood best friend. Determined to complete the task as Whistle also threatens to kill his mother, Karthi makes multiple attempts. Finally, atop a hill, he confesses his intention, and a not-yet-named Dorothy calls out society and its ever-present gender discrimination.

Recognising the woman in his friend through the symbolically biblical apple, and like Snow White’s huntsman, Karthi also bids her to flee. He then evocatively pleads with the hospital staff and brings back the body of an orphaned beggar to convince Subbu’s brothers. However, the story becomes a fairy tale when the huntsman assumes the role of a prince, sealing the closing frame with a true love’s kiss from a newly named Dorothy.

Also Read: Vaazhai is heartwarming and gut-wrenching in equal parts

The chosen family

In Snow White’s story, seven dwarfs become her chosen family. She cooks, cleans and takes care of them as the womanly figure she represents. However, to reinforce her femininity in opposition, the dwarfs become stereotypes, exposed to ridicule, which is also extended to the real world.

This, however, is not the case for Dorothy. The seven transgender women who adopt her, take care of her, show her the joys of womanhood and community, become her pillars. By their support and love, she becomes Dorothy. Subbaraj’s egalitarian vision captures the transgender community’s togetherness during the nirvaanam as a spectacle of beauty and celebration. This culminates in the symbolic death that both Snow White and Subbu undergo in the presence of their chosen family, and in their renewal.

Also Read: 10 Tamil films that explore the essence of cinema

End is a beginning

The film’s fairytale-like ending is its strongest point, as it uses the familiarity audiences have with tropes like the true-love’s kiss to challenge their ideological expectations of romantic fulfilment. Ironically, a critical audience was more familiar with the ordinariness of death in the film and its visual language of violence than the gentleness of its kiss.

In interviews promoting the film, it unsurprisingly raised questions about whether men cry and can experience the full spectrum of emotions. The film has forever opened the template of a fairy tale and made it possible for each of us to be the protagonist. But is it an adaptation of Snow White? No. Dorothy draws from a collective imagination to suggest that the magic of a fairy tale lies not in the promise of a happy ending but in the audience’s willingness to believe in one.

(Views are personal. Edited by Majnu Babu).

journalist-ad